Format and link fix 2000/bmeyer, update .gitignore
This commit is contained in:
1 parent
ea79092508
commit
acdb26d5c4
4 files changed
+82
-93
No files matched your search
@@ -1 +1,2 @@
|
|||||||
bmeyer
|
bmeyer
|
||||||
|
lavabus.glic
|
||||||
+79
-91
@@ -1,11 +1,11 @@
|
|||||||
# Best Utility
|
# Best Utility
|
||||||
|
|
||||||
Bernd Meyer
|
Bernd Meyer
|
||||||
Monash University, Melbourne, Australia
|
Monash University, Melbourne, Australia
|
||||||
1/832 Blackburn Rd
|
1/832 Blackburn Rd
|
||||||
Clayton, VIC 3168
|
Clayton, VIC 3168
|
||||||
Australia
|
Australia
|
||||||
http://byron.csse.monash.edu.au/
|
<https://web.archive.org/web/20030212213342/http://byron.csse.monash.edu.au/realindex.html>
|
||||||
|
|
||||||
## To build:
|
## To build:
|
||||||
|
|
||||||
@@ -27,7 +27,7 @@ In a video window (white text on black background):
|
|||||||
./bmeyer < michael.pgm > michael.glic
|
./bmeyer < michael.pgm > michael.glic
|
||||||
```
|
```
|
||||||
|
|
||||||
Compare the michael.pgm to the screen output.
|
Compare the `michael.pgm` to the screen output.
|
||||||
|
|
||||||
To test that you are compressing and decompressing the same way the
|
To test that you are compressing and decompressing the same way the
|
||||||
author was, try:
|
author was, try:
|
||||||
@@ -42,8 +42,8 @@ Also try in a reverse video window:
|
|||||||
./bmeyer < michael.pgm 2>/dev/null | ./bmeyer > new.pgm
|
./bmeyer < michael.pgm 2>/dev/null | ./bmeyer > new.pgm
|
||||||
```
|
```
|
||||||
|
|
||||||
Compare the michael.pgm to the screen output. Compare the new.pgm file
|
Compare the [michael.pgm](michael.pgm) to the screen output. Compare the
|
||||||
to the michael.pgm file.
|
`new.pgm` file to the [michael.pgm](michael.pgm) file.
|
||||||
|
|
||||||
Create a large reverse video xterm, say 200 columns wide and try:
|
Create a large reverse video xterm, say 200 columns wide and try:
|
||||||
|
|
||||||
@@ -63,7 +63,8 @@ Decompress that smaller glic-file:
|
|||||||
./bmeyer -2 200 < lavabus.glic2 > new.pgm
|
./bmeyer -2 200 < lavabus.glic2 > new.pgm
|
||||||
```
|
```
|
||||||
|
|
||||||
Compare the new.pgm file to the lavabus.pgm file by viewing them.
|
Compare the `new.pgm` file to the [lavabus.pgm](lavabus.pgm) file by viewing
|
||||||
|
them.
|
||||||
|
|
||||||
## Judges' remarks:
|
## Judges' remarks:
|
||||||
|
|
||||||
@@ -94,25 +95,23 @@ to set your FPU to use 64 bit mode. See the extra build lines
|
|||||||
in the Makefile, and read the author's remarks below.
|
in the Makefile, and read the author's remarks below.
|
||||||
|
|
||||||
If you cannot work out how to get into 64 bit mode, you can
|
If you cannot work out how to get into 64 bit mode, you can
|
||||||
try using -ffloat-store if you compile with GCC (this may have
|
try using `-ffloat-store` if you compile with GCC (this may have
|
||||||
a performance penalty). The resulting binary will have a good
|
a performance penalty). The resulting binary will have a good
|
||||||
chance to produce portable files, but due to the resulting
|
chance to produce portable files, but due to the resulting
|
||||||
double-rounding (first internally to 80 bit, then to 64 bit
|
double-rounding (first internally to 80 bit, then to 64 bit
|
||||||
on writing the value to memory), there is a small but very real
|
on writing the value to memory), there is a small but very real
|
||||||
chance any given file produced might not be portable.
|
chance any given file produced might not be portable.
|
||||||
|
|
||||||
The makefile defaults to -O3 and no `asm()` call.
|
The [Makefile](Makefile) defaults to `-O3` and no `asm()` call.
|
||||||
|
|
||||||
## Author's remarks:
|
## Author's remarks:
|
||||||
|
|
||||||
GLICBAWLS
|
This program is called `GLICBAWLS`
|
||||||
|
|
||||||
A) Function
|
#### Function
|
||||||
===========
|
|
||||||
|
|
||||||
"GLICBAWLS" stands for:
|
`GLICBAWLS` stands for "Grey Level Image Compression By Adaptive Weighted Least
|
||||||
|
Squares".
|
||||||
"Grey Level Image Compression By Adaptive Weighted Least Squares".
|
|
||||||
|
|
||||||
And that's exactly what this program does --- feed it a .PGM file
|
And that's exactly what this program does --- feed it a .PGM file
|
||||||
(either raw [i.e. P5] or ascii [i.e. P2]) on stdin, and it will
|
(either raw [i.e. P5] or ascii [i.e. P2]) on stdin, and it will
|
||||||
@@ -131,7 +130,7 @@ and then
|
|||||||
./bmeyer < michael.glic > michael.decoded.pgm
|
./bmeyer < michael.glic > michael.decoded.pgm
|
||||||
```
|
```
|
||||||
|
|
||||||
As it turns out, glicbawls compresses greyscale images (or, more
|
As it turns out, `glicbawls` compresses greyscale images (or, more
|
||||||
precisely, "natural" greyscale images) better than any other
|
precisely, "natural" greyscale images) better than any other
|
||||||
program I am aware of (with the exception of the not-yet-published
|
program I am aware of (with the exception of the not-yet-published
|
||||||
program developed for my PhD thesis). Of course, this might take
|
program developed for my PhD thesis). Of course, this might take
|
||||||
@@ -142,25 +141,25 @@ output to stderr (assuming white text on black background). If you
|
|||||||
have trouble recognizing the image, try squinting at it ;-).
|
have trouble recognizing the image, try squinting at it ;-).
|
||||||
|
|
||||||
If you still have trouble, simply use a terminal or xterm with
|
If you still have trouble, simply use a terminal or xterm with
|
||||||
more than 80 columns, and tell glicbawls about it by giving the
|
more than 80 columns, and tell `glicbawls` about it by giving the
|
||||||
number of columns as an argument. For example
|
number of columns as an argument. For example
|
||||||
|
|
||||||
```sh
|
```sh
|
||||||
./bmeyer 260 <lavabus.pgm >lavabus.glic
|
./bmeyer 260 <lavabus.pgm >lavabus.glic
|
||||||
```
|
```
|
||||||
|
|
||||||
will allow glicbawls to use up to 260 columns, which makes things
|
will allow `glicbawls` to use up to 260 columns, which makes things
|
||||||
much more recognizable.
|
much more recognizable.
|
||||||
|
|
||||||
Still running out of space? Need to compress those images just a
|
Still running out of space? Need to compress those images just a
|
||||||
tad more? And maybe you can handle some loss due to the
|
tad more? And maybe you can handle some loss due to the
|
||||||
compression? If so, you can use glicbawls' "near lossless"
|
compression? If so, you can use `glicbawls`' "near lossless"
|
||||||
compression mode. In that mode, the decoded pixel values are
|
compression mode. In that mode, the decoded pixel values are
|
||||||
allowed to differ from tbe originals, but there is an upper limit
|
allowed to differ from the originals, but there is an upper limit
|
||||||
on the magnitude of the difference. For example, if a maximum
|
on the magnitude of the difference. For example, if a maximum
|
||||||
error of 2 is allowed, an original pixel value of 37 could be
|
error of 2 is allowed, an original pixel value of 37 could be
|
||||||
decoded as 35,36,37, 38 or 39. In order to use this mode, simply
|
decoded as 35,36,37, 38 or 39. In order to use this mode, simply
|
||||||
give the maximum allowed error as an argument, with a dash ('-')
|
give the maximum allowed error as an argument, with a dash (`-`)
|
||||||
before it. For example
|
before it. For example
|
||||||
|
|
||||||
```sh
|
```sh
|
||||||
@@ -183,8 +182,8 @@ terminal for the progress display, and
|
|||||||
|
|
||||||
will decompress the result on such a terminal.
|
will decompress the result on such a terminal.
|
||||||
|
|
||||||
But wait, there is more --- you can also feed glicbawls .PPM files
|
But wait, there is more --- you can also feed `glicbawls` .PPM files
|
||||||
(i.e. colour images), raw or ascii, your choice. Glicbawls will
|
(i.e. colour images), raw or ascii, your choice. `Glicbawls` will
|
||||||
compress and decompress them just fine. However, it only does
|
compress and decompress them just fine. However, it only does
|
||||||
"reasonably well" on them; It beats PNG easily, but there are
|
"reasonably well" on them; It beats PNG easily, but there are
|
||||||
certainly programs out there that can compress colour images
|
certainly programs out there that can compress colour images
|
||||||
@@ -192,61 +191,54 @@ considerably better. And don't even *think* about using it for
|
|||||||
so-called "artistic" images (i.e. anything that wasn't scanned
|
so-called "artistic" images (i.e. anything that wasn't scanned
|
||||||
from a photo or camera)....
|
from a photo or camera)....
|
||||||
|
|
||||||
*****************************************************************
|
### WARNING
|
||||||
* *
|
|
||||||
* WARNING WARNING WARNING WARNING WARNING WARNING WARNING *
|
|
||||||
* *
|
`Glicball` is rather CPU and FPU intensive. Don't run it on anything slow.
|
||||||
* *
|
Things start to be usable around 300+MHz, with 600+ being highly desirable.
|
||||||
* Glicball is rather CPU and FPU intensive. Don't *
|
|
||||||
* run it on anything slow. Things start to be *
|
|
||||||
* usable around 300+MHz, with 600+ being highly *
|
|
||||||
* desirable. *
|
|
||||||
* *
|
|
||||||
*****************************************************************
|
|
||||||
|
|
||||||
|
|
||||||
|
|
||||||
B) Compile Instructions
|
|
||||||
=======================
|
|
||||||
|
|
||||||
Unlike most compression program, glicbawls makes heavy use of
|
### Compile Instructions
|
||||||
|
|
||||||
|
Unlike most compression program, `glicbawls` makes heavy use of
|
||||||
floating point maths --- and not all FPUs are created equal. Most
|
floating point maths --- and not all FPUs are created equal. Most
|
||||||
importantly, the x86 and 68k FPUs use 80 bit floating point
|
importantly, the x86 and 68k FPUs use 80 bit floating point
|
||||||
formats internally, while most other processors use IEEE 64 bit
|
formats internally, while most other processors use IEEE 64 bit
|
||||||
formats by default. If not taken care of, this means that a
|
formats by default. If not taken care of, this means that a
|
||||||
glicbawls file compressed on one CPU cannot generally be
|
`glicbawls` file compressed on one CPU cannot generally be
|
||||||
decompressed on another.
|
decompressed on another.
|
||||||
|
|
||||||
Fortunately, just about all current FPUs can be put into IEEE 64
|
Fortunately, just about all current FPUs can be put into IEEE 64
|
||||||
bit mode (or at least something close enough for
|
bit mode (or at least something close enough for
|
||||||
glicbawls). Unfortunately, there is no standard way of doing
|
`glicbawls`). Unfortunately, there is no standard way of doing
|
||||||
so. For this reason, the build file contains *three* compile
|
so. For this reason, the build file contains *three* compile
|
||||||
lines; One for machines that already use 64 bit mode by default
|
lines; One for machines that already use 64 bit mode by default
|
||||||
(most RISC processors), one for linux/x86 machines using libc4,
|
(most RISC processors), one for linux/x86 machines using libc4,
|
||||||
libc5 or glibc2.0, and one for linux/x86 machines using glibc2.1
|
libc5 or glibc2.0, and one for linux/x86 machines using glibc2.1
|
||||||
(glibc2.1 no longer exports the __setfpucw function, necessitating
|
(glibc2.1 no longer exports the `__setfpucw()` function, necessitating
|
||||||
the use of gcc inline assembly. *Grumble*).
|
the use of gcc inline assembly. \*Grumble\*).
|
||||||
|
|
||||||
So, if you are building on a machine that does not, by default,
|
So, if you are building on a machine that does not, by default,
|
||||||
use IEEE 64 bit floating point doubles, you'll have to define Y to
|
use IEEE 64 bit floating point doubles, you'll have to define `Y` to
|
||||||
be a command that switches it into that mode. If you fail to do
|
be a command that switches it into that mode. If you fail to do
|
||||||
so, your glicbawls executable will still be able to decompress its
|
so, your `glicbawls` executable will still be able to decompress its
|
||||||
own compressed files, but you may be unable to exchange files with
|
own compressed files, but you may be unable to exchange files with
|
||||||
glicbawls on other machines.
|
`glicbawls` on other machines.
|
||||||
|
|
||||||
|
|
||||||
C) Obfuscation
|
### Obfuscation
|
||||||
==============
|
|
||||||
|
|
||||||
Most of the obfuscation of this program was driven by the
|
Most of the obfuscation of this program was driven by the
|
||||||
desperate struggle to fit all of glicbawls' features into code
|
desperate struggle to fit all of `glicbawls`' features into code
|
||||||
that fits the IOCCC's size limits. All identifiers names are
|
that fits the IOCCC's size limits. All identifiers names are
|
||||||
single-character, which was only possible by ruthless exploitation
|
single-character, which was only possible by ruthless exploitation
|
||||||
of scope. There is a function M() that handles nearly all input
|
of scope. There is a function `M()` that handles nearly all input
|
||||||
from stdin, handles all output to stdout, and also recursively
|
from stdin, handles all output to stdout, and also recursively
|
||||||
calculates one of the mathematical expressions needed for error
|
calculates one of the mathematical expressions needed for error
|
||||||
modelling. There is a function that calculates (A^(-1)*b)*x with A
|
modelling. There is a function that calculates `(A^(-1)*b)*x` with `A`
|
||||||
a matrix and b and x being vectors, and does so in a very
|
being a matrix and `b` and `x` being vectors, and does so in a very
|
||||||
efficient way --- but one would be hard pressed to find it. There
|
efficient way --- but one would be hard pressed to find it. There
|
||||||
is an arithmetic coder that is even less recognizable. A lot of
|
is an arithmetic coder that is even less recognizable. A lot of
|
||||||
loop variables don't get initialized, but instead the code is
|
loop variables don't get initialized, but instead the code is
|
||||||
@@ -257,7 +249,7 @@ meaning all the time, and the differences between compressing and
|
|||||||
decompressing are handled in rather subtle ways all over the
|
decompressing are handled in rather subtle ways all over the
|
||||||
program. The string that holds the ascii values for displaying the
|
program. The string that holds the ascii values for displaying the
|
||||||
progress image doubles as a description on how to find a pixel's
|
progress image doubles as a description on how to find a pixel's
|
||||||
causal neighbours. And then there are a few #define's that really
|
causal neighbours. And then there are a few `#define`s that really
|
||||||
are just in there to save a few characters, but as an added
|
are just in there to save a few characters, but as an added
|
||||||
"benefit" make the source ever more unreadable.
|
"benefit" make the source ever more unreadable.
|
||||||
|
|
||||||
@@ -265,31 +257,30 @@ In short --- running it through the preprocessor and the
|
|||||||
pretty-printer will give you something that looks slightly less
|
pretty-printer will give you something that looks slightly less
|
||||||
like line noise and slightly more like a C program, but unless you
|
like line noise and slightly more like a C program, but unless you
|
||||||
are a true wizard, it is unlikely to gain you any insights into
|
are a true wizard, it is unlikely to gain you any insights into
|
||||||
what is actually going on....[0]
|
what is actually going on....\[0\]
|
||||||
|
|
||||||
|
|
||||||
D) Bugs, Assumptions and TODOs
|
### Bugs, Assumptions and TODOs
|
||||||
==============================
|
|
||||||
|
|
||||||
Glicbawls assumes that characters are 8 bit wide, and that the
|
`Glicbawls` assumes that characters are 8 bit wide, and that the
|
||||||
character set used is ASCII. If one of these isn't true, all hell
|
character set used is ASCII. If one of these isn't true, all hell
|
||||||
will break loose.
|
will break loose.
|
||||||
|
|
||||||
The .PGM headers are not checked very thoroughly --- glicbawls
|
The .PGM headers are not checked very thoroughly --- `glicbawls`
|
||||||
will happily try to encode lots of files that it shouldn't
|
will happily try to encode lots of files that it shouldn't
|
||||||
touch. The old adage of "garbage in, garbage out" holds in that
|
touch. The old adage of "garbage in, garbage out" holds in that
|
||||||
case. Furthermore, even if glicbawls detects an incorrect input,
|
case. Furthermore, even if `glicbawls` detects an incorrect input,
|
||||||
it fails to provide a meaningful error message, and instead
|
it fails to provide a meaningful error message, and instead
|
||||||
simply aborts.
|
simply aborts.
|
||||||
|
|
||||||
When decompressing a near-losslessy encoded image, the maximum
|
When decompressing a near-lossless encoded image, the maximum
|
||||||
allowed error is required as a command line parameter. This should
|
allowed error is required as a command line parameter. This should
|
||||||
really be saved in the compressed file!
|
really be saved in the compressed file!
|
||||||
|
|
||||||
Glicbawls relies on the decimal representation of all integers
|
`Glicbawls` relies on the decimal representation of all integers
|
||||||
having less than 255 digits. While ANSI C does not guarantee this,
|
having less than 255 digits. While ANSI C does not guarantee this,
|
||||||
it seems rather unlikely that anyone in the foreseeable future
|
it seems rather unlikely that anyone in the foreseeable future
|
||||||
would use images with 10^255 rows, columns or different levels of
|
would use images with `10^255` rows, columns or different levels of
|
||||||
grey. Also, it is assumed that any integer used can be cast to a
|
grey. Also, it is assumed that any integer used can be cast to a
|
||||||
double and back without loss of precision. This limits the number
|
double and back without loss of precision. This limits the number
|
||||||
of rows, columns and grey levels to 9 quintillion, which should
|
of rows, columns and grey levels to 9 quintillion, which should
|
||||||
@@ -302,14 +293,13 @@ million in a lottery. But if it happens to you, don't say I
|
|||||||
didn't warn you! Instead, go out and buy a lightning rod and a
|
didn't warn you! Instead, go out and buy a lightning rod and a
|
||||||
lottery ticket ;-)
|
lottery ticket ;-)
|
||||||
|
|
||||||
At one point, a pointer to int is used as the target of a "%1[#]"
|
At one point, a pointer to int is used as the target of a `"%1[#]"`
|
||||||
conversion in a scanf, which makes gcc rather unhappy, but
|
conversion in a scanf, which makes gcc rather unhappy, but
|
||||||
shouldn't really cause anyone any trouble. The same goes for a
|
shouldn't really cause anyone any trouble. The same goes for a
|
||||||
couple of assignments which are used as truth values.
|
couple of assignments which are used as truth values.
|
||||||
|
|
||||||
|
|
||||||
E) Algorithm
|
### Algorithm
|
||||||
============
|
|
||||||
|
|
||||||
An exhaustive explanation of the algorithm used would go beyond
|
An exhaustive explanation of the algorithm used would go beyond
|
||||||
the scope of an info file, and would also be quite difficult in
|
the scope of an info file, and would also be quite difficult in
|
||||||
@@ -321,11 +311,11 @@ expected value is calculated by creating a least squares predictor
|
|||||||
of order 12 based on all of the previously encoded/decoded
|
of order 12 based on all of the previously encoded/decoded
|
||||||
pixels. However, the contribution of each pixel is weighted
|
pixels. However, the contribution of each pixel is weighted
|
||||||
according to its Manhattan-distance from the current pixel,
|
according to its Manhattan-distance from the current pixel,
|
||||||
D. That weight used is pow(0.8,D). [1][2][3]
|
D. That weight used is `pow(0.8,D)`. \[1\] \[2\] \[3\]
|
||||||
|
|
||||||
|
|
||||||
In a similar way, the prediction *errors* for all previous pixels
|
In a similar way, the prediction *errors* for all previous pixels
|
||||||
are combined --- a weighted average (with weight pow(0.7,D)) of
|
are combined --- a weighted average (with weight `pow(0.7,D)`) of
|
||||||
the squares of all previous prediction errors is taken, and the
|
the squares of all previous prediction errors is taken, and the
|
||||||
square root of the (appropriately scaled) result is called sigma.
|
square root of the (appropriately scaled) result is called sigma.
|
||||||
|
|
||||||
@@ -343,22 +333,22 @@ arithmetic decoder provides the information which half the actual
|
|||||||
value is in. In both cases, the interval borders are adjusted
|
value is in. In both cases, the interval borders are adjusted
|
||||||
accordingly, the arithmetic coder/decoder updated, and the
|
accordingly, the arithmetic coder/decoder updated, and the
|
||||||
interval halving repeated until the precise value has been
|
interval halving repeated until the precise value has been
|
||||||
en/decoded[4].
|
en/decoded\[4\].
|
||||||
|
|
||||||
|
|
||||||
[0] Yes, this could be seen as a challenge....
|
[0] Yes, this could be seen as a challenge....
|
||||||
[1] Actually, the weight is pow(0.8,D)/s, where s is the sigma
|
[1] Actually, the weight is `pow(0.8,D)/s`, where `s` is the sigma
|
||||||
used for en/decoding the particular previous pixel. Dividing
|
used for en/decoding the particular previous pixel. Dividing
|
||||||
by s is a rather arbitrary action justified only by the
|
by `s` is a rather arbitrary action justified only by the
|
||||||
improvement in results. Mathematically, I can only justify
|
improvement in results. Mathematically, I can only justify
|
||||||
dividing by s^2, or not dividing at all....
|
dividing by `s^2`, or not dividing at all....
|
||||||
[2] Obviously, these least squares predictors are not calculated
|
[2] Obviously, these least squares predictors are not calculated
|
||||||
from scratch for each pixel. Some clever reuse of earlier
|
from scratch for each pixel. Some clever reuse of earlier
|
||||||
results allows O(1) calculation, rather than the
|
results allows O(1) calculation, rather than the
|
||||||
O(previous_rows*columns) this description would suggest.
|
`O(previous_rows*columns)` this description would suggest.
|
||||||
[3] As anyone who has ever tried local least squares knows from
|
[3] As anyone who has ever tried local least squares knows from
|
||||||
bitter experience, there is a lot of numerical instability
|
bitter experience, there is a lot of numerical instability
|
||||||
associated with them. So glicbawls adds a bias towards an
|
associated with them. So `glicbawls` adds a bias towards an
|
||||||
averaging predictor to the equation system the least squares
|
averaging predictor to the equation system the least squares
|
||||||
predictor is calculated from. The weight that is given to
|
predictor is calculated from. The weight that is given to
|
||||||
this bias is constantly adjusted throughout coding/decoding,
|
this bias is constantly adjusted throughout coding/decoding,
|
||||||
@@ -370,31 +360,29 @@ en/decoded[4].
|
|||||||
iteration ends as soon as the interval is small enough to
|
iteration ends as soon as the interval is small enough to
|
||||||
guarantee decoding within the requested maximum error.
|
guarantee decoding within the requested maximum error.
|
||||||
|
|
||||||
####################################################################
|
|
||||||
|
|
||||||
Photo Credit:
|
### Photo Credit:
|
||||||
|
|
||||||
Lavabus was taken by the judge, Landon Curt Noll. Michael was
|
[Lavabus](lavabus.pgm) was taken by the judge, Landon Curt Noll.
|
||||||
provided by the author. Lenna is a 1972 Playboy centerfold.
|
[Michael](michael.pgm) was provided by the author. [Lenna](lenna.glic) is a
|
||||||
|
1972 Playboy centerfold.
|
||||||
|
|
||||||
michael.pgm
|
- [michael.pgm](michael.pgm)
|
||||||
|
|
||||||
The author's Godchild and nephew.
|
The author's Godchild and nephew.
|
||||||
|
|
||||||
lavabus.pgm
|
- [lavabus.pgm](lavabus.pgm)
|
||||||
|
|
||||||
A bus that was trapped by lava from Kilauea volcano in
|
A bus that was trapped by lava from Kilauea volcano in Hawaii, USA. Nobody
|
||||||
Hawaii, USA. Nobody was in the bus at the time, BTW.
|
was in the bus at the time, BTW. Photo date: 1981.
|
||||||
Photo date: 1981.
|
|
||||||
|
|
||||||
lenna.glic
|
- [lenna.glic](lenna.glic)
|
||||||
|
|
||||||
A November 1972 Playboy centerfold was scanned in long ago and
|
A November 1972 Playboy centerfold was scanned in long ago and has been used
|
||||||
has been used for image compression research since then. Playboy
|
for image compression research since then. Playboy originally threatened to
|
||||||
originally threatened to prosecute unauthorized use, but
|
prosecute unauthorized use, but eventually granted that, having been in use
|
||||||
eventually granted that, having been in use for image compression
|
for image compression testing for so long, it was now a useful benchmark.
|
||||||
testing for so long, it was now a useful benchmark. (Note: This
|
(Note: This picture doesn't show very much.)
|
||||||
picture doesn't show very much.)
|
|
||||||
|
|
||||||
## Copyright and CC BY-SA 4.0 License:
|
## Copyright and CC BY-SA 4.0 License:
|
||||||
|
|
||||||
|
|||||||
+1
-1
@@ -24,7 +24,7 @@ Arne "Timwi" Heizmann,Arne_"Timwi"_Heizmann,null,null,timwi@gmx.net,Germany,null
|
|||||||
Baruch Nissenbaum,Baruch_Nissenbaum,null,null,baruch@eng.tau.ac.il,null,null);
|
Baruch Nissenbaum,Baruch_Nissenbaum,null,null,baruch@eng.tau.ac.il,null,null);
|
||||||
Bas de Bakker,Bas_de_Bakker,null,null,bas@bbwt.demon.nl,null,null);
|
Bas de Bakker,Bas_de_Bakker,null,null,bas@bbwt.demon.nl,null,null);
|
||||||
Ben Lynn,Ben_Lynn,https://crypto.stanford.edu/~blynn/,null,benlynn@gmail.com,null,@bmxlynn);
|
Ben Lynn,Ben_Lynn,https://crypto.stanford.edu/~blynn/,null,benlynn@gmail.com,null,@bmxlynn);
|
||||||
Bernd Meyer,Bernd_Meyer,http://byron.csse.monash.edu.au/,null,bmeyer@cs.monash.edu.au,null,null);
|
Bernd Meyer,Bernd_Meyer,https://web.archive.org/web/20030212213342/http://byron.csse.monash.edu.au/realindex.html,null,bmeyer@cs.monash.edu.au,null,null);
|
||||||
Brent Burley,Brent_Burley,null,null,brent.burley@disney.com,null,null);
|
Brent Burley,Brent_Burley,null,null,brent.burley@disney.com,null,null);
|
||||||
Brian Westley,Brian_Westley,http://www.westley.org,null,brian@westley.org,null,null);
|
Brian Westley,Brian_Westley,http://www.westley.org,null,brian@westley.org,null,null);
|
||||||
Bruce Holloway,Bruce_Holloway,null,null,null,null,null);
|
Bruce Holloway,Bruce_Holloway,null,null,null,null,null);
|
||||||
|
|||||||
|
Can't render this file because it contains an unexpected character in line 23 and column 6.
|
+1
-1
@@ -837,7 +837,7 @@ Contest </I></FONT></CENTER><BR>
|
|||||||
<LI TYPE=square>Best RFC Obfuscation (<A HREF="years.html#1996_rcm">1996 rcm</A>)
|
<LI TYPE=square>Best RFC Obfuscation (<A HREF="years.html#1996_rcm">1996 rcm</A>)
|
||||||
</UL><BR>
|
</UL><BR>
|
||||||
|
|
||||||
<LI TYPE=none><A NAME="Bernd_Meyer"></A><B><a href="mailto:bmeyer@cs.monash.edu.au">Bernd Meyer</a></B> -- <A HREF="http://byron.csse.monash.edu.au/">http://byron.csse.monash.edu.au/</a>
|
<LI TYPE=none><A NAME="Bernd_Meyer"></A><B><a href="mailto:bmeyer@cs.monash.edu.au">Bernd Meyer</a></B> -- <A HREF="https://web.archive.org/web/20030212213342/http://byron.csse.monash.edu.au/realindex.html">https://web.archive.org/web/20030212213342/http://byron.csse.monash.edu.au/realindex.html</a>
|
||||||
<UL>
|
<UL>
|
||||||
<LI TYPE=square>Best Utility (<A HREF="years.html#2000_bmeyer">2000 bmeyer</A>)
|
<LI TYPE=square>Best Utility (<A HREF="years.html#2000_bmeyer">2000 bmeyer</A>)
|
||||||
</UL><BR>
|
</UL><BR>
|
||||||
|
|||||||
Reference in new issue
Block a user